Giving Up on Homeschool Co-ops

Why is the homeschool community so pushy about its co-ops?

When I tell someone that I homeschool, do you know what their first question is? “What co-op are you in?”

They automatically assume that I am a member of a co-op if I tell them that I homeschool. I can’t escape this assumption.

Yet, after trying various co-ops, I’ve given up on the co-op experience for our homeschool. They don’t work well for us.


I used to be afraid to admit that I homeschool without a co-op, but I’m letting go of the feelings of guilt and obligation surrounding co-ops.

I’m finally learning that it’s ok to homeschool without a co-op.


It’s taken me years to admit this to myself and feel at peace with our decision. The guilt still creeps in occasionally, but I just remind myself of a few truths whenever I struggle with whether I should be in a homeschool co-op.


Co-ops are rarely truly free.

While many co-ops are free or low cost, I find that there always seems to be added expenses such as snacks, backpacks, and bags. Or there can be the expense of supplies for co-op class -things you need to purchase for your children’s classes or things you need to enhance a class that you are teaching. Whenever I’ve taught or helped teach a class, it never fails that I need to pick up a few supplies and not all of them have been reimbursed.


The co-op curriculum may not perfectly fit your style.

Depending on the type of co-op you join, you may need to adjust your curriculum or your year plan to fit around the co-op classes. Some co-ops follow certain curriculum while others teach enrichment classes that are an “extra” enhancement to your year. Either way, you might need to reevaluate your plan for the year to make room for the subjects and curriculum being taught in the co-op.


There might not be class options that interest each of your children.

If you have more than one child that you are homeschooling, you might find it an added challenge to select the classes that best fit each child. What might work well for one child might not work at all for a child with a different learning style. A co-op might not offer what each of your children need for a particular school year. And if you need to be present during the co-op day, your children might need to take “filler” classes just to have a full schedule during the day.


Getting out the door each week might be more trouble than it’s worth.

If you’ve ever had to pack up several children and get them out the door in a timely manner, you know the struggle involved. No amount of planning the night before can make it easier when the baby suddenly has a dirty diaper, the toddler throws a tantrum over her shoes, and older children start arguing. It can be utterly exhausting to get out the door and the value of the co-op might not offset the work it takes to get there on time each week.


Co-op moms can form cliques.

You are now an adult and you thought you were safe from the middle school mess of cliques and mean girls, right? Wrong. I have found that co-ops tend to foster this type of mentality. There are lots of comparisons as moms form smaller groups within the co-op. What should feel like a unified co-op begins to feel unfriendly as a whole because some members have segmented themselves into smaller groups.


No one needs added drama.

Each co-op I have participated in has had its fair amount of mama drama. There is always someone upset about something or someone who is frustrated with another member. When you put a group of tired moms in a room together, the result is not always pleasant and gracious conversation. You might want to skip the added drama and stress that comes with a co-op.


Your time is valuable.

A true co-op requires that all moms volunteer in some way. This means that you’ll spend time prepping lessons, teaching, cleaning, or watching little ones. I don’t know about you, but since I spend all my other days teaching my own children, I don’t want to spend extra time teaching everyone else’s children or creating more lesson plans.


You can provide a tailored education.

Homeschooling allows you to provide an individualized education for each of your children – working at their pace and addressing their learning styles and learning needs. A co-op is like a tiny school in many ways. The classes are geared for the middle of each age range, which means that they might not always address your child’s educational needs.


Flexibility and free time are valuable assets in your homeschool.

Co-ops can cause you to feel tied down to a set schedule. They can also use an entire school day, leaving you only 4 days (or less) at home to complete schoolwork. One of the biggest benefits of homeschooling is the flexibility to tailor your schedule, have time off whenever you need it, take extra field trips, and allow your children lots of time for free play and exploration.


Co-ops can lead to burnout.

Did you think a co-op would save you from burnout? That’s not always the case. In some ways, I think a co-op can contribute to burnout, because you have to prepare extra lessons and plans for the co-op classes that you teach or co-teach. Having to be at the co-op every week can be tiresome and finding a substitute if you are sick or out of town can be challenging. Co-ops can feel like another responsibility piled on top of the huge undertaking of homeschooling. This added responsibility can lead to feeling tired and burned out.


You know your kids best.

God gave you those kids, and if He called you to homeschool them, then He’ll equip you for that job. You really can homeschool your own children well without a co-op. No one knows their needs, learning styles, and learning challenges better than you do. Therefore, you are well equipped to address all of their needs and challenge them to continue to love learning.


A friend of mine said something to me that has really stayed with me for several years. She said, “God didn’t call you to homeschool everyone else’s kids. He called you to homeschool yours.”

Wow! That was such a great reminder to me that my first job is my own family. I know my kids best and I’m called to educate them first and foremost.


For now, I’m devoting myself to the task of homeschooling my own family while finding enrichment activities outside of formal co-ops.

Now, don’t get me wrong! Homeschool co-ops can work well for many people.

They can provide a sense of community and support. They allow you access to people with expertise or passion in certain subject areas. They give you a chance to teach a class on a topic you enjoy. They allow your kids to fellowship and spend time with other homeschool friends. They can help keep you and your children accountable and motivated through the homeschool year as you meet together with other like-minded homeschool families.

Co-ops can be an asset to your homeschool.

However, they aren’t necessary for homeschool success. You can effectively homeschool without a co-op. Your kids will be ok without the co-op experience and you might find that your weeks are more relaxed without having that one more thing on your to do list.


Don’t feel guilty if homeschool co-ops aren’t quite your style.

Be brave! Skip the homeschool co-op and create a custom education for your children. And take a few extra field trips (and days off) while you’re at it!


Further Reading

Why We Quit Our Co-op

The 10 Homeschool Traps

Evaluating Your Time as a Homeschool Mom

Homeschooling is a Full Time Job

How Do You Do It All?


12 thoughts on “Giving Up on Homeschool Co-ops

    1. Thanks for sharing your experience. My kids prefer to learn without a co-op. They would rather take field trips or have days at the park than sit in a classroom. I struggled with feeling guilty for several years since many of my friends were in co-ops. I’m finally learning that it’s ok to homeschool without a co-op and that my kids have plenty of learning opportunities without one.

  1. Thank you for sharing! I am starting to homeschool my eldest child and so many ladies tell me to join a co-op. There is one just 5 minutes from my home but I can’t get myself out the door. I did not really understand why but I think you just listed all my thoughts. Ha! This definitely helped me.

    1. I’m glad it was helpful. Sometimes co-ops can be wonderful things but I think new homeschoolers should start slow their first year and just enjoy learning alongside their child. And it can be very stressful to try to get out the door each week. My kids much preferred to be on our own schedule and have field trips and park days and do things on our own time.

  2. Thank you for this! Very timely, especially since the new school year is coming up and I get asked this a lot. I even considered this morning joining one, but soon remembered why we started homeschooling in the first place. Just because it works for one doesn’t mean it works for all. No more guilt! Thank you so much for the reminder. I don’t have to feel guilty for not being in a co-op.

  3. We have homeschooled for 7 years now and have never been in a co-op. My oldest 2 will be in 8th and 6th grade this year, and I actually wanted to put them in one. I applied and reached out to our local co-op, and was denied because I am having a baby in November, and would have to “take time off.” So….I will be continuing without a co-op for the long haul, because I was so put off by that. I may get together with a few families for something small.

    1. That’s crazy that you were denied joining the co-op! A co-op should be all families working together and contributing as best they can. Other members should be ready to step in the gap for those who need time off for new babies or for sickness or other family issues. I think that’s really terrible!
      I wouldn’t be opposed to getting together informally with a few other families for joint learning opportunities, but I too am staying away from organized co-ops for right now. We have too much fun in our crazy homeschool and I feel like our schedule is already very full.

  4. I recently joined a co-op for my about to be 2nd grader. We have not started yet. It is a parent-led co-op and I will be responsible for teaching K-1 science. My daughter and I began a blog about our life and intend on adding some interesting projects and activities.. I also work about 30 hours per week. I am starting to really worry that I don’t have the extra time to commit and I wonder if I will be stonewalled from other co-ops if I decide to take her out at this point. I think as I have become more comfortable with my own skills to teach her, I have become less comfortable with her being in a co-op. This article really hit home for me. Thanks for sharing your perspective.

    1. You’re welcome! I hope you find what works for you this year. Co-ops can be a great source of encouragement and motivation, but they aren’t for everyone. I had a hard time letting go of the feeling that my kids were missing out if I wasn’t in a co-op. And I struggled with the amount of planning and prep. I feel like I can barely keep up with my own homeschool at this point, so I felt I couldn’t commit to a co-op.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

CommentLuv badge