My Homeschool Grading Rubric

This post may contain affiliate links. For more information, visit my disclosure page


I decided to start issuing grades for a few subjects in our homeschool now that my daughter is in 4th grade.
Ok, so how on earth do I give grades? I’ve never done this before!

I had to resist making a very complex grading formula or rubric for myself. I knew that this would 1) confuse me
2) confuse my daughter
3) be impossible to maintain for an extended period of time

I didn’t want to create a complicated system that would fail within a few months. And let’s be honest, if the grading system is complex then I have all kinds of annoying math to figure out for myself.

After discussing my grading options with my husband, we both agreed that I needed to keep it very simple for our first foray into record keeping and grades.

I decided to create a very simple rubric that could be used in every subject.

Here’s what I did:

Every paper is worth only 10 points (easy math, people!).

  • 5 points for content
  • 2.5 for formatting
  • 2.5 for critical thinking

For these points the answers have to be correct (math problems), contain the required elements, (writing and composition) and include correct spelling and grammar.

These points includes writing problems and numbers correctly, staying in margins, writing in correct paragraphs, indenting, using a proper outline format, titling papers, etc. Handwriting neatness will also be included in this section.

Critical Thinking
Not every assignment will have this component. However, critical thinking will entail going above and beyond just the simple requirements and demonstrating that thought, time, and effort was put into each assignment. (And if the assignment elicited lots of whining and complaining then these points won’t be awarded….).

So there’s my very, very simple grading rubric that will hopefully keep me accountable to grading assignments and enable me to keep grade records for the rest of the year.

I’m sure over time the rubric will become more complicated and some assignments may have their own rubric or checklist. But for now I thought we would start with the simplest possible method.

So, now I can write down assignment grades on my simple excel spreadsheet and track our progress!

Do you need to start giving grades in your homeschool?

You can read why I made the choice to begin giving grades right here.

And while you’re in planning mode you might enjoy these posts:

How Long is a Homeschool Day
How I Planned for Our Homeschool YearOur Homeschool Schedule

This is a great resource if you have older students and are starting to think about high school record keeping.

There are also lots of great planners to help you keep organized homeschool records! Try one of these!

Ultimate Homeschool Planner
Eclectic Homeschooler’s Plan Book
180 Day Homeschooling Planner



One thought on “My Homeschool Grading Rubric

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

CommentLuv badge